« February 1, 2004 | Main | February 5, 2004 »

February 4, 2004 Archives

February 4, 2004

Staff Misses Deadline; Council Cancels Call.

The GNSO Council's call for this week has been cancelled. The call's purpose would have been to discuss a staff-manager-prepared summary of constituency statements for the new registry-services PDP. That summary has not yet been sent to the council, but is expected within the next 24 hours, we're told. The council now plans to discuss this report on February 19.

This is turning into an increasingly absurd pattern of staff promises that are then broken. I'm tempted to talk about a systemic failure that began when the new wishful-thinking PDP was adopted during the reform process.

Read This.

Susan Crawford has background information on today's congress hearing: At that hearing, the Subcommittee will be considering a new Whois bill creating new penalties for people who provide false data when registering a domain name.

The hearing will be webcast. A witness list is not available.

Later: The committee's schedule page refers to this as an oversight hearing; on the subcommittee's page, it's now a legislative hearing on HR 3754 (text here; thanks to Susan Crawford).

WHOIS hearing notes

Some preliminary notes from listening to the WHOIS hearing's live webcast: Testimonial was heared from Tim Trainer (IACC), J Scott Evans (INTA; former GNSO Council member and IPC chair), Rick Wesson (registrar constituency CTO), and Mark Bohannon (Copyright Coalition on Domain Names). All witnesses supported the bill.

Rick Wesson in CongressBesides the usual "whois is important" statements, Rick Wesson testified about his fraudit system, and pointed out that registrars have no business incentives to verify contact data supplied to them as long as they are paid. He seemed to suggest that additional lelgislation was needed in order to create such incentives. (I may have mis-heared him on that point, though.)

J Scott Evans testifyingJ Scott Evans repeatedly said that ICANN efforts on WHOIS accuracy were busy discussing procedure, not substance. I wonder how he came to that conclusion -- Task Force 3 is, after all, chaired by a member of the IPC, and (I'm hearing) currently attempting to reach out and collect input on available accuracy verification mechanisms. Outreach seems stalled, though, because relevant contact information is lacking.

I'm planning to re-listen to the webcast once it's available; I may have more then.

About February 2004

This page contains all entries posted to No Such Weblog in February 2004. They are listed from oldest to newest.

February 1, 2004 is the previous archive.

February 5, 2004 is the next archive.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.

Creative Commons License
This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Powered by
Movable Type 3.35